Dwain Northey (Gen X)

There is something profoundly comforting about the phrase “temporary facility.” It has the soft, disposable sound of a paper cup—use it briefly, throw it away, move on with your conscience mostly intact. Temporary means necessity. Temporary means emergency. Temporary means nobody has to ask long, slow questions about permanence, profit, or history.
Which is why it is so reassuring to learn that we are building permanent places for all this temporary activity.
After all, nothing says “short-term administrative process” quite like pouring concrete that will outlive several generations of elected officials. Nothing whispers “just until the paperwork clears” like zoning approvals, multi-year construction contracts, and infrastructure designed to stand proudly through earthquakes, recessions, and whatever new slogan replaces the worst of the worst in the next campaign cycle.
One begins to suspect that the word temporary is doing the kind of heavy lifting normally reserved for mythological creatures or unpaid interns.
We are told, of course, that these facilities exist only to house people briefly before deportation. A logistical waypoint. A bureaucratic bus stop. Just a pause in motion. And yet, curiously, history teaches that when governments invest in cages that do not rust, the cages tend to find reasons to remain occupied. Empty permanence is politically inefficient. Concrete, like nature, abhors a vacuum.
This is not cynicism; it is simply the résumé of the past.
America, after all, has always possessed a remarkable talent for declaring something finished while quietly preserving the mechanism that made it possible. Slavery ended—except for the small textual footnote allowing forced labor for the incarcerated. Segregation ended—except for the neighborhoods, schools, and systems that somehow remembered the old map perfectly. Wars end. Emergencies end. Powers granted during crises, however, develop a touching reluctance to retire.
And now we discover that deportation, too, may require architecture sturdy enough to survive the very future in which it is supposedly unnecessary.
Perhaps this is merely prudent planning. Perhaps officials simply fear a catastrophic shortage of people to detain and want to ensure adequate storage capacity for decades to come. One would hate to run out of room for temporary humanity. The headlines would be dreadful: Nation Forced to Confront Policy Without Adequate Warehousing.
Better to prepare.
Still, there is an awkward historical echo in the idea of building durable institutions around the controlled labor and confinement of a legally diminished class of people. Not the same, of course—history never repeats, we are told, it only rhymes. And America has always preferred its rhymes faint enough to ignore.
Yet the constitutional clause remains, quietly grammatical, patiently available: freedom guaranteed—unless incarcerated. A loophole with excellent real estate. A sentence fragment that has done more work than many full amendments.
So when permanent detention spaces rise in the name of temporary necessity, some observers experience a mild historical déjà vu. Not outrage, exactly—outrage requires surprise. More a slow recognition, like hearing an old melody played on newer instruments.
But surely we are different now. We have better signage. Cleaner fonts. Committees. Oversight hearings scheduled firmly in the future. And above all, we have language—carefully polished language that transforms endurance into urgency and infrastructure into compassion.
Nothing humane has ever been built so solidly.
In the end, perhaps the question is not why permanent facilities are being constructed for temporary purposes. Perhaps the real question is why we continue to believe that permanence ever arrives wearing its true name. History prefers euphemism. Concrete prefers silence. And both, once set, are famously difficult to remove.
Still, we can rest easy knowing that everything is under control, strictly provisional, and absolutely not the sort of thing future generations will study with puzzled expressions and long, uncomfortable pauses.
Just a temporary measure.
Built to last forever.









You must be logged in to post a comment.